Alte teste facute cu scene reale si cu programul direct
.
Autodesk Maya:
Placi reale nemodate (FirePro V5700=HD4670 pret 1500 lei si FX 580=9500GT pret 850 lei)
FirePro v5700 -
[email protected] GHz 1280x1024 --> 17.4 fps in smooth shade (motocicleta netexturata)
FirePro v5700 -
[email protected] GHz 1280x1024 --> 11.1 fps in smooth shade (insula texturata)
Quadro FX 580 -
[email protected] GHz 1280x1024 --> 50 fps in smooth shade (motocicleta netexturata)
Quadro FX 580 -
[email protected] GHz 1280x1024 --> 50 fps in smooth shade (insula texturata)
Quadro FX1700 - Q9550@2,8 GHz 1680x1050 --> 47 fps in smooth shade (motocicleta netexturata)
Quadro FX1700 - Q9550@2,8 GHz 1280x1024 --> 85 fps in smooth shade (insula texturata)
Placi modate:
HD4870-800/4400@FirePro V8700 Q6600@3GHz 1680x1050 --> 13 fps in smooth shade (motocicleta netexturata)
4670@FirePro V5700 Q6600@3GHz 1280x1024 --> 11.0 fps in smooth shade (insula texturata)
4670 - unmodded - Q6600@3GHz 1280x1024 --> 8.9 fps in smooth shade (insula texturata)
8800 Ultra - unmodded - Q6600@3ghz 1680x1050 --> 14 in smooth shade (motocicleta netexturata)
8800 Ultra@Quadro FX 4600 Q6600@3ghz 1680x1050 --> 50 fps in smooth shade (motocicleta netexturata)
HD3870 - unmodded -
[email protected] 1680x1050 --> 21 fps in smooth shade (motocicleta netexturata)
HD3870@FireGL V7700 -
[email protected] 1680x1050 --> 25 fps in smooth shade (motocicleta netexturata)
8600GT@Quadro FX 570 -
[email protected] 1280x1024 --> 61 fps in smooth shade (motocicleta netexturata)
8600GT@Quadro FX 570 -
[email protected] 1280x1024 --> 80 fps in smooth shade (insula texturata)
8800GT@Quadro FX 3700 -
[email protected] 1280x1024 --> 70 fps in smooth shade (motocicleta netexturata))
8800GT@Quadro FX 3700 -
[email protected] 1280x1024 --> 85 in smooth shade (insula texturata)
Autodesk 3D Max :
=================================================
Video Card: unmodded Radeon 3870 (775mhz Core, 1125mhz DDR4)
Display Type:1920x1080 Samsung 32"
Core 2 Duo @1860mhz
3GB DDR2 RAM, Windows XP 64bit
All Triangles ON, D3D
No AA
File Name | FPS
=================================================
4viewports.MAX | 42.1053
8direct.MAX | 278.552
8omni.MAX | 278.164
8spot.MAX | 266.667
blitting.MAX | 458.225
dualplanes.MAX | 458.54
geometry1.MAX | 314.795
geometry2.MAX | 157.398
multitex.MAX | 4.2328
rasterize.MAX | 266.667
textured1.MAX | 210.497
textured2.MAX | 86.7679
textured3.MAX | 101.585
transpar.MAX | 159.949
wireframe1.MAX | 14.4474
wireframe2.MAX | 13.8626
Comp High: 109.104
Comp Low: 100.454
=================================================
Video Card: Radeon 3870@FireGL 7700 (775mhz Core, 1125mhz DDR4)
Display Type:1920x1080 Samsung 32"
Core 2 Duo @1860mhz
3GB DDR2 RAM, Windows XP 64bit
All Triangles ON, D3D
No AA
File Name | FPS
=================================================
4viewports.MAX | 118.483
8direct.MAX | 346.021
8omni.MAX | 346.021
8spot.MAX | 328.407
blitting.MAX | 601.926
dualplanes.MAX | 624.35
geometry1.MAX | 362.319
geometry2.MAX | 154.879
multitex.MAX | 4.43203
rasterize.MAX | 252.972
textured1.MAX | 256.674
textured2.MAX | 125.51
textured3.MAX | 107.021
transpar.MAX | 135.575
wireframe1.MAX | 213.371
wireframe2.MAX | 94.5776
Comp High: 198.6
Comp Low: 151.641
=================================================
Video Card: Quadro FX1700 --- q9550@2,83GHz
Display Type: 1680x1050 22"
File Name | FPS
=================================================
4viewports.MAX | 145.349
8direct.MAX | 228.571
8omni.MAX | 217.155
8spot.MAX | 200.0
blitting.MAX | 1021.1
dualplanes.MAX | 616.808
geometry1.MAX | 179.426
geometry2.MAX | 145.419
multitex.MAX | 0.780281
rasterize.MAX | 227.739
textured1.MAX | 280.689
textured2.MAX | 131.97
textured3.MAX | 164.096
transpar.MAX | 179.727
wireframe1.MAX | 34.7182
wireframe2.MAX | 33.2152
Comp High: 126.287
Comp Low: 126.677
=================================================
Video Card: 8800GT@FX3700 --- q9550@3,4GHz
Display Type: 1680x1050 22"
File Name | FPS
=================================================
4viewports.MAX | 168.35
8direct.MAX | 607.903
8omni.MAX | 638.978
8spot.MAX | 607.903
blitting.MAX | 876.68
dualplanes.MAX | 1238.39
geometry1.MAX | 446.429
geometry2.MAX | 290.698
multitex.MAX | 1.82859
rasterize.MAX | 640.205
textured1.MAX | 623.441
textured2.MAX | 177.778
textured3.MAX | 288.184
transpar.MAX | 355.619
wireframe1.MAX | 41.0228
wireframe2.MAX | 35.621
Comp High: 236.068
Comp Low: 228.535
Testul in 3D max nu-i cel mai relevant dar este cel mai apropiat de realtitate fata de mincinosul specviewperf. Din pacate nu sunt scene potrivite asa cum este in maya. Testele sunt facute de cel care m-a ajutat cu modul, el lucreaza in 3D max si are un 8600GT, un 8800GT si un HD3870. El mi-a zis ca HD3870 este mult mai slab ca 8800GT modat si nemodat + ca este instabil mai ales in OpenGL. Restul testelor sunt facute de altii
.
Deci atat pentru Maya cat si pentru Max feriti-va de ATi
. Sa nu uit sa zic ca la ATi s-au descoperit buguri mai ales in maya, cu nvidia merge perfect totul
.
Nu-i de mirare ca 80% dintre developeri folosesc nvidia. Praf sunt astia de la ATi... nu au bani sa investeasca in driveri. Situatia se cam repeta peste tot. Avand in vedere ca ATi nu are nici un fel de proteste anti-mod sau limitare intre Radeon si FirePro\FireGL as putea sa confirm ca FirePro V8700 care costa 1500$ este la fel de prost ca HD4870 in mai toate cazurile. Asa cum FirePro V5700 ete la fel de prost ca HD4670 si FireGL V7700 care costa 3000 lei este al fel de prost ca HD3870. Asa ca developerilor aveti grija ce teapa cumparati pentru a va continua productia.
Spor la bani
.
Viziteaza-ne pe Facebook
Urmareste-ne pe Twitter
Vezi ce facem pe YouTube